1)
In 1974, a scientific report described a previously unreported
nervous disease of goats which was believed to be caused by a virus. This was followed by a report of an arthritic disease
in goats presumably caused by the same agent. Shortly afterward the viral cause of these conditions was confirmed and the
virus characterized. The development of a diagnostic serologic test was soon reported along with the observation that a high
percentage of goats in the United States appeared to have experienced the virus. Investigation into the transmission of the
disease suggested that virus was spread through colostrum and milk of infected dams and that virus free herds might be maintained
by raising kids in isolation.
2) Nomenclature
The nervous disease first reported in 1974,
was named Viral Leukoencephalomyelitis of Goats (VLG). When it became apparent that arthritis could also result from the same
virus infection, the name of the disease was changed to Caprine Arthritis Encephalitis Syndrome (CAE). It is now apparent
that the virus also produces changes in the lung and udder. The name CAE however still remains in place.
3) The Causative Virus
Knowledge of how a disease is transmitted
is often the key to developing a successful program for preventing the spread of infection. To date, all published reports
suggest that goats become infected with CAE virus as newborn kids. Experimental evidence for this is persuasive. Kids delivered
either naturally or taken by cesarean-section, but deprived of colostrum and fed cow milk remain free of the virus despite
the fact that their dams are infected. If taken by cesarean-section or delivered naturally, but allowed to nurse colostrum
or milk from an infected doe, kids will show evidence of virus infection. These findings indicate that kids are not infected
in utero or during passage through the birth canal; but do pick up infection when nursing colostrum or milk from infected
dams. This suggests that control of the spread of new infections might be achieved by separation and artificial rearing of
kids at birth.
4) Transmission of CAE Virus
Knowledge of how a disease is
transmitted is often the key to developing a successful program for preventing the spread of infection. To date, all published
reports suggest that goats become infected with CAE virus as newborn kids. Experimental evidence for this is persuasive. Kids
delivered either naturally or taken by cesarean-section, but deprived of colostrum and fed cow milk remain free of the virus
despite the fact that their dams are infected. If taken by cesarean-section or delivered naturally, but allowed to nurse colostrum
or milk from an infected doe, kids will show evidence of virus infection. These findings indicate that kids are not infected
in utero or during passage through the birth canal; but do pick up infection when nursing colostrum or milk from infected
dams. This suggests that control of the spread of new infections might be achieved by separation and artificial rearing of
kids at birth.
5) Prevalence of CAE
One aspect of the CAE syndrome which
has proven most troubling to the US goat industry was a published report that a high percentage of goats tested from all over
the United States showed serological evidence of infection with CAE virus. Of 1160 goats tested from 24 states, 81 showed
antibody to CAE virus using the agar gel immunodiffusion (AGID) test. It can be assumed that animals with antibody to CAE
virus have been exposed to and infected by the virus. The only exception to this could be young kids with detectable antibody
picked up from the dam's co lostrum. Unlike most bacterial diseases, where a strong antibody response means that the animal
has cleared itself of the invading organism, infections with CAE and other retroviruses are likely to persist in the animal
despite a high antibody titer. Therefore, it is probably true that a large percentage of antibody positive goats carry persistent
infections. However, it does not necessarily follow that the majority of these goats are likely to show clinical signs of
the CAE syndrome. The factors which contribute to the onset of clinical signs in animals infected with the virus are unknown.
6)
The major problem associated with this high prevalence
of infected US goats is not the actual incidence of clinical disease so much as the negative perception of prospective goat
buyers and regulatory officials confronted with a positive AGID test. Already some countries importing US goats, like Kenya,
have refused or destroyed shipments of goats which turned out to be antibody positive. Economic restraints such as this increase
pressure on the goat industry to aggressively tackle the CAE problem.
7) The Clinical Signs of CAE
Two separate distinct syndromes
are caused by the CAE virus, a neurological disease in the spinal cord and brain of young kids and a joint infection of older
goats resulting in arthritis. How individual animals infected with CAE virus escaped one or the other or both syndromes remains
a mystery. The clinical signs of the two syndromes are as follows.
8) The Nervous Form of CAE
The nervous form of CAE was the
first to be described. All breeds of goats can be affected as can both sexes, and most individuals first show signs between
one and four months of age. The problem is one of progressive weakness (paresis) of the hind limbs leading to eventual paralysis.
The early paresis may be perceived as lameness, incoordination or weakness in one or both rear legs. Knuckling over of the
feet and difficulty in rising may follow until such time that the animal is unable to rise at all. The course of the disease
is from several days to several weeks. Despite the progressive paralysis, the kid will usually remain bright and alert and
continue to eat and drink. Mild pneumonia may be present. If the correct diagnosis is made, the animal is often euthanized
since there is no known treatment for the condition.
9)
The development of these signs results from inflammation
in the spinal cord induced by the virus. Nerves which control motor function of the hind limbs are progressively destroyed.
In spite of the ongoing inflammation, there is little or no change observed in the cerebrospinal fluid on CSF tap nor in the
complete blood count (CBC). Diagnosis is based on recognition of the clinical signs and confirmation depends on observation
of the characteristic changes seen microscopically in the spinal cord at the time of postmortem examination.
10)
In older goats, a clinical variation of the nervous form
of CAE has been observed which is clinically indistinguishable from Listeriosis. Signs include circling, head tilt and facial
nerve paralysis. On postmortem examination, the characteristic lesions of CAE virus are found in the brain stem rather than
the cervical spinal cord.
11) The Arthritic Form of CAE
The joint form of CAE most
often appears clinically between one and two years of age. There can be great variability in the progression and severity
of signs. Some goats can be severely crippled within a few months while others may show only intermittent lameness or stiffness
for years without ever becoming completely debilitated. A ''typical'' case would fall somewhere in between. The disease is
usually first recognized as a gradually developing lameness accompanied or followed by swelling of the joints. Swelling is
most often noted in the front knees (carpi) and can also be seen in the hock and stifle joints. As the condition progresses,
joint pain and stiffness become more apparent. The animal may spend a good deal of time lying down, will begin to lose weight
and develop a rough hair coat. In severely affected joints, the range of motion may become limited and goats are forced to
walk around on their carpi. No specific cure is known for CAE arthritis. The well-being of affected goats may be improved
by proper foot trimming, extra bedding and administration of anti-inflammatory drugs such as aspirin.
12)
As in the nervous form, the complete blood count in goats
with CAE arthritis will most likely be normal. Fluid taken from affected joints, however, may show changes suggestive of CAE.
These include a reddish brown discoloration, increased volume, low viscosity and an increase in mononuclear cells. All joint
fluid aspirates should be cultured for bacteria, chlamydia and mycoplasma since these organisms can also cause arthritis in
goats. In addition to these infectious causes, traumatic injury and poor conformation can also lead to joint problems. Keep
in mind, that not all swollen joints or stiff limbs are CAE arthritis.
13) Other Clinical Syndromes of CAE
Young kids with the nervous
form of CAE may show a concurrent pneumonia. On postmortem examination, goats with either the nervous form or the arthritic
form may show characteristic changes in the lungs attributable to CAE virus infection. These changes are described as interstitial
infiltration of mononuclear cells. Pneumonia due to CAE virus however is rarely seen as the only clinical sign in infected
goats.
14)
Another interesting microscopic finding from postmortem
examination is a similar mononuclear infiltration of the mammary gland of infected does. There is some speculation, but no
certain confirmation, that the well known condition of hard udder seen in some does at freshening may be due to CAE virus.
This mysterious condition is often misdiagnosed as udder edema or mycoplasma mastitis.
15)
In arthritis of goats due to CAEV, clinical signs are
limited to the joints and surrounding structures. Affected goats may initially show soft fluid swellings over the joints,
especially in the bursae of the front knees. Over a period of weeks to months pronounced lamenss may develop and progress
to the point where animals are unable to extend the limbs and may walk on their knees. Radiographs may reveal extensive calcification
of the soft tissues surrounding the joint. Joint fluid will contain excessive numbers of mononuclear cells. Postmortem examination
will reveal extensive proliferation of the synovial membrane. In other animals the advance arthritic signs may not be so severe
and these animals show only intermittent pain, reluctance to move and progressive weight loss.
16)
A serum test can be run which demonstrates that the goat
has been exposed to the virus, but the test will not absolutely confirm that arthritis is due to the virus infection. No treatment
or vaccine is available for arthritis due to CAEV. A separate chapter on CAE follows because of its importance.
17) Prevention and Control
Suggestions for the control of
CAE infection and plans for the establishment of CAE free herds have been published. These plans are based on current knowledge
concerning the transmission of the virus and controversy has arisen regarding the practicability and effectiveness of these
programs. Perceptions of how reasonable these suggestions are, may depend largely on the interest to establish a CAE virus
free herd. A hobbyist with two grade does in the backyard for home milk consumption may not be motivated sufficiently to change
the management in order to raise CAE free kids. On the other hand, an internationally reputable breeder with sales of registered
stock may in fear of a positive AGID test want strongly to establish and maintain a CAE free herd. A control plan would include
the following:
1. A serologic survey of all animals presently in the herd.
2. Culling of all AGID positive animals if economically feasible.
3. Repeated AGID testing at 6 month intervals to insure that all positive
individuals were identified.
4. If some or all AGID positive animals are maintained for the time
being, the strategy then shifts to the creation of a new CAE free herd founded with the next kid crop.
5. At the next kidding season all births are observed and the kids
are removed from their does immediately. These kids are either deprived of colostrum, fed only frozen colostrum from does
previously identified as AGID negative, or fed pasteurized colostrum. Only experienced herdsmen with a strong background in
kid rearing should attempt to raise colostrum deprived kids since these animals are susceptible to a variety of dangerous
infections if not given protective immunoglobulin injections. Pasteurization of colostrum is considered a poor alternative
because heating to 161F causes the liquid colostrum to congeal. Slow pasteurization at 131F for 1 hour may minimize this problem
but this is time consuming. Feeding colostrum from AGID test negative does may be the best compromise although it must be
pointed out that an occasional seronegative doe may actually be shedding the virus and a small number of new kids may be infected.
6. Kids should be raised in separate quarters from does and fed cow
milk or milk replacer until weaning.
7. All kids should be tested at 6 months of age and periodically thereafter
to insure their seronegative status. Seropositive animals should be culled immediately.
8. As the new replacement herd matures, older previously seropositive
animals, still in the herd, should be systematically culled. Any animal showing clinical signs of CAE should be culled immediately.
9. In this manner the incidence of CAE in a herd can be dramatically
reduced in one generation and possibly eliminated in a few generations. For this to occur, conscientious adherence to the
program is necessary.
18)
Hopefully research into the workings of CAE virus will
continue at the same dynamic pace observed over the last eight years. Clarification of the mechanisms of transmission and
the animal's responses to infection could lead to better recommendations for control of the disease.